East Coast Water Taxi
East Coast Water Taxi runs you about 15 minutes from Las Croabas to Icacos, sets you up on the sand with umbrellas and a cooler, and comes back for you later. Pick it for the time ashore: this is the option where the island, not the boat, is the day.

This is a drop-off, not a boat for the day. You park at Kayak Village in Las Croabas, walk behind the building to the dock and look for the blue boat. The ride across is about 15 minutes. On Icacos the crew sets out beach umbrellas and a cooler with water, soft drinks and local beer, then leaves you to it until the pickup.
The package adds more than a plain water taxi. You get a mask and snorkel, an optional snorkel session and an optional 45-minute historic hike with a local guide. Icacos once had a limestone quarry on its southern part, with a short railroad to the pier, according to Wikipedia.
Be ready for an empty island. Discover Puerto Rico lists no bathrooms, food vendors, stores, chair rentals, permanent shade or lifeguards on Icacos. The listing tells you to bring your own food, and there is no restroom until you're back at Las Croabas. If that sounds like too much roughing it, the Double Dip catamaran has a restroom and lunch on board. If it sounds perfect, read the water taxi guide for the walk-up options too.
Leave the car at Kayak Village in Las Croabas and walk behind the building to the dock. The boat is blue.
A quick run across open water to the beach.
The crew sets up shade and drinks on the sand.
Join the optional snorkel session or the 45-minute historic hike, or just float in the shallows.
The water taxi returns for the ride back to the dock.
Read next:
About 15 minutes each way from Las Croabas, according to the listing. Discover Puerto Rico puts the crossing at 15 to 20 minutes by boat.
No. The cooler holds water, soft drinks and local beer, but the listing tells you to bring your own food. There is nothing to buy on Icacos.
No. It drops you on the beach and returns later to take you back. Umbrellas, the cooler and a local guide stay with the group.
Fares change with the season, the operator and the size of your group, so check the live fare on the booking page. If you go walk-up instead, Discover Puerto Rico says to bring cash, as not all water taxis take cards.
Ready to book
A 15-minute water taxi hop to Icacos, umbrellas and a cooler waiting on the sand, and most of the day on the island.
From San Juan: Van, Boat & Beach BBQHotel pickup in San Juan, a short boat from Las Croabas and about four hours of beach camp with a BBQ on Icacos.★ 4.3 · 7 hours
Private Half-Day Charter to Icacos or PalominoYour own boat for up to six for four hours: Icacos or Palominos, guided snorkeling, drinks, snacks and towels.★ 5.0 · 4 hours
Icacos Full-Day Catamaran TripThe classic Fajardo boat day: sail out of Puerto del Rey, beach time on the cay, a reef swim and a barbecue lunch on board.★ 4.8 · 6 hours